Chill-Out Summer Supper with Tomato Water Granita Starter

Dinner parties are arranged a little differently –– they are much smaller, but just as much fun as we enjoy friends and good food!

My friends Neil and Caitlyn, above,  were physically at a safe distance at our party, but it didn’t stop good conversation, food, and wine. Our dog Bailey is always right in the middle of things.

From tomato water granita (with seafood or vegetarian) to chilled seafood stew, everything was made early in the day, so it was all pretty effortless when it came time to eat. More time to visit with friends.

Physical distancing (note, I did not say “social” distancing, we’re still being social, just “physically” apart) is difficult, but if you want to meet with your friends, there are certainly ways to make it happen. I’ve been having two to three people for Saturday night dinner on my very large, wrap-around front porch. We’ve worked out a routine that keeps everyone safe: wearing masks upon arrival and getting settled in, table distance, setting out separate plates of serving utensils, and plenty of sanitizing wipes around. You can put separate pitchers of water or even bottles of wine at each area. It becomes routine, and is not that big a deal! We’re still together!

The Menu: I always prepare a menu so that everyone can get excited about what we’re going to enjoy as soon as they arrive!

I have a new favorite summer delight: Tomato Water Granita

This granita is flavored up as you would a Bloody Mary, and is one of the most refreshing things you can eat on a hot, humid summer’s day. It goes far beyond satisfying with its cold texture and spice. It really hits the spot and I hope you try it.

First you have to start with one of my favorite ingredients –– fresh tomato water. I’m talking the clear liquid from the tomato, not tomato juice which includes a lot of the tomato pulp. It takes a while to strain, but is well worth it!

On a hot humid Summer’s day at our place, afternoon tea might be baguette, a little Vermont cheese, and a glass of chilled tomato water with a little treat of cherry tomatoes and olives. The tomato water may be pale in color, but packed with intense tomato flavor.

I avoid making shrimp cocktail in the traditional way at all costs, so I wanted to come up with something a little different. I often serve little glasses of fresh tomato water in hot summer. It’s such a surprise because this clear or barely pink liquid is packed with so much flavor, and can be dressed up any way you would a tomato: add little skewers of cherry tomatoes, olives, a basil leaf, mozzarella, etc. I thought turning it into a granita would delightful, and it was one of the best things I’ve made in a while. This in one of my new favorites, and I’ll be making it again and again.


Tomato Water Granita Cocktail

(also vegan version)

First, make the tomato water:

The clear water you see along the knife when you slice into a fresh, ripe tomato is extremely flavorful and makes a great virgin or otherwise cocktail, with a little patience. Choose fat, local tomatoes that feel heavy in the hand, but are not overly soft or mushy. This is what I make when the farm stands have boxes of “canning” tomatoes for sale, or, a table of overripe ugly tomatoes!

If you use a tea towel to drain the tomatoes, the liquid will be nearly clear. If you use cheesecloth, it will be a pink color. I prefer the tea towel method because it is a surprise when someone takes a sip, but this time around, I decided I wanted the pink cast and drained it through the cheesecloth.

  • 4 or 5 big heavy heirloom tomatoes, ugly ones are perfect
  • Coarse sea salt

Line a fine mesh strainer with a brilliantly clean tea towel or multiple layers of cheesecloth. Working over the strainer, cut ripe heirloom tomatoes into chunks and salt liberally.

Let this drain naturally, don’t squeeze it; the resulting drained liquid will be almost clear, a surprise, because it looks anemic, yet packs incredible fresh tomato juice flavor. This will take a while, so if you are impatient, I suggest you make it the night before, put it in the refrigerator, and out of your mind, until the next morning. It takes some time, so it is best made the day before anyway.

Before serving, you’ll want it nice and cold. It will keep for several days, if it lasts that long. But it won’t.

To make Granita Cocktail:

  • 1 quart of tomato water
  • A few splashes of hot sauce
  • 1 tsp. Worcestershire sauce
  • 1 tbsp. prepared horseradish
  • ¼ to ½ tsp. celery salt
  • Zest and juice of one lime
  • ½ tsp. salt
  • ½ tsp. freshly ground black pepper

Mix everything together and place in a shallow dish and stick in the freezer.

After 45 minutes, you’ll have some ice crystals start to form. Just rake through with the tines of your fork. Break up any clumps that may have formed, just mash them.

Freeze for about 45 minutes then run a fork around the edges. It should have started to firm up.

After a couple of hours, you’ll have a lovely texture, like an adult snow cone!

Check at 30 minutes, and rake with the fork. Continue forking at 30-minute intervals until it is at the texture you like. Cover well.

To serve, top with whatever you like. I used shrimps that I roasted and chilled. Cut them up, it is much easier to eat!

Vegetarian version: I also made one using baked tofu that was also seasoned with paprika and garlic and chilled.

Also served:

We started things off with little nibbles including spiced nuts and marinated artichoke and sun-dried tomatoes served with (Against the Grain gluten-free) baguette slices. Main course was a simple seafood stew in which I poached the cod, then chilled it all down. The broth was made from lobster stock I had stashed in the freezer and shrimp shells from the shrimp in the stew and the tomato water granita cocktail. We finished everything off with fresh blueberries and sorbet or dairy-free ice cream.

© Copyright 2020– or current year, The New Vintage Kitchen, Unatrributed use o thimaterial is strictly prohibited. reposting and links may be used, provided that credit misgiven to The New Vintage Kitchen, with active link and direction to this original post. 

The New Vintage Kitchen does not accept ads or payment for mention of products or businesses.


  1. Angela says:

    What a great idea, Dorothy. You are incredibly creative!

    1. Thank you, Angela! I have to say, with no modesty, that I was really proud of this one!

  2. this recipe is genius!!! love it!

    1. Thank you so much! It is right now my new favorite dish! I’m sure I’ll make it again and again.

  3. Oh my, that porch…the perfect ambient for a dinner with friends 😍
    This chilled tomato water is really interesting 😋

    1. I moved things around and set up the porch to keep it that way the rest of summer so it’s ready for meal time. There is a massive sugar maple right next to it that keeps it really cool, and it’s on the east side of the house. Even in a driving rain, we can still eat out there!

      1. Wonderful! Being able to enjoy it rain or sun is so great! I always loved the outdoor spaces! Definitely it is a requirement for my cottage by the sea when the moment will come 😉

      2. Absolutely! My cottage by the sea will also have a large wrap around!

  4. A perfect summer party! Love such make ahead dishes. The granita is such a brilliant substitute for the traditional shrimp cocktail sauce, which I’m also far from being a fan of! 🙂

    1. Thanks!!! I will definitely serve the granita again, it got big wows!

  5. CarolCooks2 says:

    This sounds wonderful and tomatoes are one of my favourite fruits…I love the sound of the granita a lovely refreshing menu 🙂

    1. Thank you Carol, it really was refreshing!

  6. Tomato Granita. Pure genius. 🍃🍅🍤

    1. Aw, thanks! It really had a zing with the Bloody Mary flavorings, and we all enjoyed it!

  7. Great post 😁

  8. Sounds perfect! I know your friends are thrilled when they get an invite, and I love your pretty menu!

    1. Thank you! I always find it fun to create a menu and I save them. It’s fun to look at them from time to time.

  9. Awesome!👌

  10. Terrie Gura says:

    You just keep on wowing me, Dorothy! This idea is so brilliant and sounds so, so good! I saw something in the N.Y. Times Cooking newsletter the other day about pouring off salted tomato water into a dry martini. But that was just recently, so I am thinking they got such an idea from you! 🙂

    100%, I am going to make this with the last of summer tomatoes I can find.

    1. I hope you do try it, you will be hooked! I never thought of putting the tomato water in a martini, but it would be perfect. We often served it at afternoon tea in little chilled glasses with some speared cherry tomatoes or olives and a leaf of basil, brie and baguette on the side. Nothing better!

Comments are closed.