Honey Whole Wheat Sourdough English Muffins

That sounds like a mouthful, but they are easy to make, and full of flavor and nutrition!

When I was growing up, my mom made English muffins once in a while, but not as a regular part of her baking routine. She used tuna-fish cans as the mold to shape them, and as a kid I thought that was quite creative, still do! Her muffins turned out really big, but we loved them, especially with her homemade blackberry jam!

 Let’s rethink these!

 I think I made these once many years ago, using the tuna cans, and then sort of put them out of my mind. But, one cold November day, I found myself with sourdough starter discard to use, so I decided to revisit them with my own little twists. 

It’s all about the flour

        Mom made hers with white flour, white sugar, and melted butter. I jumped head-on into a total recreation to make these more heart healthy, and held my breath that it would work. 100% whole wheat bread flour would play the staring role. The brand I used was an organic bread flour from One Mighty Mill located in neighboring Massachusetts. This company stone grinds its flours on hand-carved stone mills which help to retain the natural nutrients, fiber, and flavor of the wheat. It’s pricy, but every loaf of bread I’ve made with it has had superb flavor so it is worth it! A good substitute is King Arthur organic white whole wheat flour, another recommended pantry favorite that is much easier to find, and it is also stone ground.

A little something sweet

            Goodbye white sugar, I used honey instead, and actually bumped it up a tablespoon for flavor. My “house honey” of choice is from bees that have fertilized the produce on a neighboring farm. I love using this flavorful honey, and thinking of the work the bees do to feed us all, through their pollination of our produce. If you are a vegan, you may substitute a Vermont maple syrup.

            The biggest change I made was adding the sourdough discard. I’ll do anything to avoid throwing it away! The extra moisture meant I needed to add a bit more flour, so I increased it by a third of a cup to compensate. 

If you don’t have the discard, you can still make the muffins, just cut back on the flour to two cups. I made these with my sister and they came out great!

            I didn’t have tuna cans on hand, so I used a broken quarter-cup measuring cup (I somehow snapped off the handle a while back but it’s still in my drawer) to measure out and shaped them the way my mom shaped dinner rolls, then pressed them down to flatten somewhat. The dough is pretty forgiving.

            The first rise was just about an hour, the second about a half, so this was pretty quick to put together, and really easy.

Nutrition and flavor, who could ask for more?

            Just 112 calories each, all whole grain, dairy free, 22 carbs, 2 grams of fiber, 4 grams of protein, no saturated fat, and a bit of potassium, iron, and calcium.

Such delicious flavor! I don’t think I want to buy English muffins ever again! Now, would someone please pass the blackberry jam?

Honey Whole Wheat Sourdough English Muffins

Makes 12 muffins

  • 1 cup warm water
  • 1 ½ tsp. dry active yeast
  • 1 cup sourdough starter*
  • 2 tbsp. native honey or maple syrup
  • 2 1/3 cup organic whole wheat flour, stone ground if available
  • 1 tsp. sea salt
  • 1 tbsp. olive oil

In the bowl of your stand mixer, or a large bowl, combine the water, yeast, starter if using, and honey. Let set for 15 minutes. You should see a little bubble action by then.

Add the flour, oil, and salt and using the dough hook, knead for about five minutes. Remove from the bowl and finish kneading by hand for a minute or so. The dough will still be just a bit sticky, so have the board floured. If kneading by hand, knead for around seven minutes. The dough will feel smooth and alive,

Place back in a lightly greased bowl, cover with a linen towel, and let rise until about double in size, or about an hour.

Prepare a baking tray by sprinkling with cornmeal. Remove the dough from bowl to gently deflate and start forming the muffins. You can use a bench scraper to divide the dough in half, guess, and continue halving to make 12. Or, use a quarter cup measuring cup to approximate the size. You can also weigh the dough, divide by 12, and portion accordingly.

Smooth the dough balls, stretching the sides under to the bottom, and using a cupped hand roll the bottom of the dough ball on an un-floured surface until it is nice and round. Place on the baking sheet and press down to flatten, and sprinkle with a little more cornmeal. Cover them all again and let rise for about a half hour.

Ready for their second rise.

Heat your griddle to medium high. I set mine at 350, but every griddle is different, so do a test muffin first, both for the heat and the timing. Grease the griddle, and place the muffins on to cook until the bottom is browned, then turn over. It will probably take about seven or eight minutes on the first side, and a little less on the second. Again, that test muffin will tell you all you need to know. Remember, as they cool, they will finish cooking.

You can also do this in batches in a large frying pan over medium-high heat.

Let cool, then split with a fork and enjoy! The fork split is essential if you want all those wonderful nooks and crannies! A bonus? They freeze nicely.

*Starter: No starter? That’s ok. Just cut back the flour to 2 cups and proceed with everything else the same.

Variation: Add a teaspoon of ground cinnamon!

© Copyright 2021– or current year, The New Vintage Kitchen. Unattributed use of this material is strictly prohibited. Reposting and links may be used, provided that credit is given to The New Vintage Kitchen, with  active link and direction to this original post.

The New Vintage Kitchen does not accept ads or payment for mention of products or businesses.

Supporter of:  Slow Food       Fair Trade USA       Northeast Organic Farmers Association     EcoWatch     No Kid Hungry   Hunger Free Vermont   Kiss the Ground

53 Comments Add yours

  1. Carole says:

    I am excited to try these!

    1. Thanks! They are so easy, silly easy, and it feels like such an accomplishment!

  2. I haven’t made English muffins in a long time. Your post definitely encourages me to go back to it. They look perfect. Love the addition of honey. 🙂

    1. Thank you Ronit. The honey gave it a lovely, subtle sweetness.

  3. leggypeggy says:

    Thanks for this recipe. I’m always looking for ways to use sourdough discard.

    1. My new favorite way!

  4. terrie gura says:

    These look great, Dorothy! I feel healthier just eyeing that whole grain goodness. I have made sourdough English muffins many times, but you’ve inspired me to do my next batch fully with whole wheat. I imagined they’d be dense, but your success is changing my mind!

    1. Thanks Terrie! This was a hold my breath and see what happens recipe, and I couldn’t have been more delighted! They were not dense at all, a lovely texture with lots of “nooks and crannies!” Fork split of course!

  5. Could I just order half a dozen to go, please? 🙂

  6. NancyC says:

    I love English muffins! These Honey Whole Wheat Sourdough ones sound wonderful–love everything about these! 🙂

    1. Thanks Nancy! They are a new family favorite for sure! I’m making them tomorrow for the weekend!

  7. Nancy says:

    I have never made English Muffins… and your way sounds like the best way! I am going to have to give these a try one day!

    1. I was surprised at how easy they were to make, and they came out great.

  8. I love making English Muffins! Look at all those nooks and cranny’s, perfection and delicious!

    1. Yes, all the nooks and crannies one could ever dream of!

  9. BERNADETTE says:

    I am in awe of your ability in the kitchen. I love English Muffins for breakfast but would never even dream of making them. Maybe after the New Year ….

    1. These were remarkably easy and fun to make, and certainly someone of your skill would have no trouble. But wait for a chilly January day when you need a little feeling of great accomplishment!

  10. Gail says:

    I need a Baker’s Dozen to go with my morning eggs. Just saying. 😍🍃

    1. They’re on the way!

  11. Ally Bean says:

    I’ve never tried to make anything like these. They look delicious.

    1. Thank you! It was amazing to me!

  12. NativeNM says:

    Oh these look so good! I actually have English Muffin cutters that I haven’t used yet. Guess there’s no time like the present. Just wish I could maintain sourdough starter the way you have. I’ve tried but I just don’t seem to have the knack to keep it going. Love your recipe!

    1. Thanks so much! Give the basic recipe a try if you don’t have the sourdough. Just cut back the flour to 2 cups.

  13. These look delicious! I tried making English muffins on the stove top once, but they didn’t cook all the way through. I’ll try it on the griddle next time!

    1. Yes, give it a try. If they didn’t cook through but browned, you probably had the heat a tad too high.That test muffin is a good gauge.

      1. Thank you! I’ll give them another go! 😀

  14. Carolyn Page says:

    I’ll put these in the ‘yummy recipes to try next winter’ file, Dorothy. They do look scrumptious!

    1. Thanks! They are yummy indeed!

  15. Wow, they look and sound amazing Dorothy! Once again I wish I were your neighbor and you would make these for me!
    Jenna

    1. Ah thanks! We’d have a blast!

  16. A healthy recipe.
    I must tell my people to try this simple nutritious recipe

    1. So good, and no guilt!

  17. JOY journal says:

    Now I have to try this! I’ve never made these before — and bread is kind of my specialty! Mmmm.

    1. So much fun to make!

  18. I’ve always enjoyed a well toasted English muffin for breakfast and your whole wheat version look wonderful.

  19. These muffins look wonderful. Sourdough makes them even better.

    1. Thanks! They have both sweetness and a little tang.

  20. Christy B says:

    You had me at sourdough! I don’t know what I’d do without bread 😉

    1. I know! I love bread, especially a bread with lots of flavor and texture.

  21. They look delicious!

    1. Thank you! The new favorite of all of us.

  22. Anonymous says:

    Love your blog!

    1. Why, thank you so much!

  23. You certainly are very healthy, Dorothy. You’ve done a nice job with the recipe make-over.

    1. Thanks! They really are tasty!

  24. Molly says:

    These look really good, Dorothy. Never dared make them, but if you say they are easy…

    1. They really are! My sister and I laughed while we were making them that they were easy but everyone would be in awe!

  25. Oh wow! I love my Benedict eggs on an English muffin but I never thought to make it at home ☺️ Look absolutely amazing! Those bees 🐝 are so busy to give us such a flavorful ingredient 🍯

  26. petespringerauthor says:

    It’s fun to experiment. I’ve also found honey to be an amazing substitute for sugar. Glad it worked out so well, Dorothy.

    1. Thanks Pete! It was definitely a hold-my-breath-and-see-what-happens experiment!

Leave a Reply to terrie gura Cancel reply