Cookbook Confidential: Roden, Claudia, (1996) “The Book of Jewish Food: An Odyssey from Samarkand to New York,” New York, Knopf

My friend Bernadette from New Classic Recipe (https://newclassicrecipe.com) came up with the wonderful idea to have an on-line cookbook club with some of her blog buddies. What a fun, and great way to choose a recipe or two from the books, cook them, and review them. Then, you decide if the book is worth your shelf space! Please go to her site for other reviews of this book! ~ Dorothy Grover-Read, The New Vintage Kitchen https://vintagekitchen.org
In The Book of Jewish Food, Claudia Roden takes us on a trip around the world, examining each culture’s take on Jewish cuisine. Both Ashkenazi and Sepharidic cooking are represented, with background and insights on the evolution of many traditional and non-traditional dishes.
A culinary anthropologist
Roden is a fascinating personality, born in Egypt, educated in Europe, well-traveled, and is the author of numerous works on Middle Eastern, Mediterranean, and Jewish cookery. More than a food writer, she is a cultural and culinary anthropologist who delves into her subjects from a unique historical perspective which lends much to her recipes, and their many variations.

A world of possibilities
In this book, we might find an Italian pasta and anchovy dish; mouna au lait, a north African sweet bread with milk; chittarnee, an Indian sweet and sour chicken and onion dish; a Spanish quince paste; an Iraqi potato cutlet; or, a sweet bread from the lost Jews of China.
Time to make a decision
So many possibilities from which to choose! Should I make blintzes, a little pancake filled with cheese and fruit? Kreplach, a stuffed pasta? Gefilta fish, probably not. Matzo balls? I was a little afraid to attempt this one without a Jewish grandmother in the kitchen with me. But there was no need to worry, because she explains throughout the book that there really is no one Jewish cuisine, the foods are all influenced strongly by location and local customs, no matter the country. And, they vary from house to house as well.
Potatoes, of course
I chose to make a potato kugel simply because I realized that although I’ve had this luscious potato dish more times than I can count, I had never actually made it myself! This from a potato lover. Roden said there are many variations on a potato kugel from using grated potatoes to mashed, with the addition of spices, cabbage, and even cheese. She recommended a basic grated potato version using vegetable oil rather than chicken fat, and kept it simple with just eggs and onion added. Sounded like a perfect side to me.
A hit
It was certainly a hit in our house. Easy to make using the food processor, it took quite a time to bake, but it was all hands-off time in the kitchen while the oven did the work. Husband loved it, as did I, and I’ll make it again, probably with a bit of fresh rosemary or some chives added.
Moroccan fish balls
The main dish I prepared was one I’d never had but will definitely make again. Originating from Morocco, fish balls in tomato sauce was easy to make and really delicious! Little spiced balls of white fish were simmered in a fresh tomato sauce, and they came out light and delicate, beautifully seasoned, and full of fish flavor. I put this together while the potatoes were busy baking away. Definitely a keeper.
My recommendation
It is easy to get lost in this book! It is a history book, a cultural exploration, an examination of the Jewish culture from different lenses around the world. The recipes are easy to follow, and Roden lets us know that there is such variation in most of them that it is really hard to make something that is not right. I highly recommend this book as a great resource and it already has a place on my bookshelf.
Potato Kugel

Roden offers this simple version of potato kugel, using neutral oil rather than chicken fat. Other variations include using mashed rather than grated potatoes, cheese, cabbage, and some potato flour to thicken. Russet potatoes keep the interior of the kugel light and fluffy, while the top gets nicely browned and crisp.
- 4 eggs, lightly beaten
- Salt and pepper
- 5 to 6 tbsp. neutral oil
- 1 large mild onion, grated
- 3 lb. (1 ½ kg.) Russet potatoes
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. In a bowl, lightly beat the eggs and add the salt and pepper, oil, and onion. I grated my onion in the food processor.
I also grated the peeled potatoes in the food processor to save time. Stir them quickly into the egg mixture so they do not discolor.
Pour in a buttered, wide baking dish and bake for about an hour. I baked mine for 1 hour 15 minutes. Then, increase the heat to 450 to continue browning for just a few minutes if necessary.
While this was baking, I made the fish recipe, and everything was ready when it needed to be.
Boulettes de Poisson à la Sauce Tomate
Moroccan Fish Balls in Tomato Sauce

In Egypt, Roden said these balls were called ‘blehat,’ and their round shape made them a special dish for the New Year. However, she prefers the spiced Moroccan version which I’ve included here. There were no good large tomatoes at the markets, so I used canned whole peeled tomatoes I chopped up, and took advantage of the juice in the can to further enhance the flavor.
The sauce:
- 3 cloves garlic, finely minced
- 2 tbsp. neutral oil
- 2 large tomatoes, peeled and chopped, OR, I substituted most of a can of whole peeled tomatoes plus its juice
- 3 tbsp. tomato paste
- 1 tsp. sugar, or to taste
- Salt
- ¼ to ½ tsp. cayenne pepper, or hot chili
For the fish balls:
- 1 lb. (500 g.) ground white fish (I used cod)
- 4 tbsp. dry white bread crumbs or matzo meal
- 1 egg, lightly beaten
- ¼ tsp. ground ginger
- ¼ tsp. ground cinnamon
- ¼ tsp. allspice
- A good pinch of nutmeg
- Salt and pepper
- 3 tbsp. finely chopped coriander or parsley
- 1 lemon, cut in wedges
Make the sauce first. Fry the garlic in a wide pan in oil until the aroma rises. Add the tomatoes, tomato paste, sugar, salt, and cayenne. You can also use a chili pepper, removing it when you find the sauce hot enough,
Add 2 cups of water (or juice from canned tomatoes), bring to a boil, then let simmer, mostly covered, until well flavored. I cooked mine for about a half hour for the tomato paste to really blend in well, then it simmered some more with the fish balls.
Make the balls. Mix all the ingredients together and work to a firm paste with your hands. I did not have a meat grinder, so I used the food processor, carefully, just very short pulses, about 10. You don’t want to over pulse.
Form little balls about the size of a walnut, and drop them in the gently simmering sauce. Cook for 20 minutes, turning them once. Serve with the lemon wedges. This was delicious with the kugel.
Since I have the better part of a tin of matzo meal left, perhaps I’ll give a try at some matzo ball soup…
© Copyright 2024– or current year, The New Vintage Kitchen. Dorothy Grover-Read. Unattributed use of this material is strictly prohibited. Reposting and links may be used, provided that credit is given to The New Vintage Kitchen, with active link and direction to this original post.
The New Vintage Kitchen does not accept ads or payment for mention of products or businesses.
Supporter of: Slow Food Fair Trade USA Northeast Organic Farmers Association EcoWatch Let’s Save Our Planet No Kid Hungry Hunger Free Vermont Environmental Working Group World Central Kitchen Sustainable America

What an interesting book! I can see getting this for my friend’s annual Hanukkah party!
Such a good book, thanks! It would make a perfect gift.
I like the sound of this neither of which I have made I always slice potatoes and cook and flake fish but never have I ground it and made fish balls it sounds flavourful.
I’ve never made anything like this either Carol, and they were scrumptious.!
Will certainly cook the Moroccan fish balls. They look delicious.
They were such a pleasant surprise! They will definitely be part of my rotation.
That potato kugel is calling my name. Thanks, Dot, for another great review.
Thank you Bernie for all the work you do in putting this together! It’s great to see what the others pick to cook!
What a neat idea and what a fun book!
I’m so glad I got the chance to review it, and I’m now quite happy I own it.
A yummy share and, yes indeed, Jewish cooking transcends into many cultures and for many reasons. .
Thank you! It’s a great book. I felt I couldn’t go wrong no matter which recipe I cooked!
That book sounds like such a treasure! I can understand why it’s a keeper.
Wonderful, approachable recipes and their variations Laurie! Plus, delightful history lessons!
What an interesting collection of recipes this book has! I love both recipes! Must be absolutely delicious! 😋
We were really pleased, and both recipes were simple and approachable to the home cook, Jewish or not!
This book sounds so interesting with different areas of the world sharing their versions of Jewish foods. I’m glad you liked the recipes you chose, the Potato Kugel sounds especially good.
They were both amazing Jenna, and tasted really good together!
You’ve found a great collection of recipes to choose from. Like you, I’m a potato person and the Kugel would be first on my list.
It certainly caught my eye Jan, and I’ll be making it again I’m sure!
I know this book. Excellent. Great recipes you chose.
I’m really glad I got the book Jovina, and I’ll be trying more!
That potato kugel is making eyes at me! thanks for sharing, looks great
Thanks! It was super easy as well, and not much hands-on time.
I have this book! The fish balls look delish! You should try gefilte fish! It is so delicious and not more difficult than making the fish balls!
I feel empowered now to try making more Jewish dishes! One important thing the book stresses is that there are countless versions of all the dishes and no right or wrong way really, so jump in the deep end!
Roden’s books are a treasure, and her recipes always work. Great choice of dishes, and so well executed! 🙂
Thank you! It is a treasury!
That was me again. I need to remember to log in each time when I comment here. Not sure why! 🙂
Oh, I love the idea of getting lost in a cookbook, then you know it is a good one!
Yes! This one has so much going for it, I’m so glad I got the opportunity to review it.
Yum—I’m eyeing that Potato Kugel, since I’m so fond of potatoes! 🙂
Thanks Nancy! So easy, and really tasty!
Interesting – there is a lot we can learn by being open to trying different types of cuisine.
Yes, and all the variations therein!
These recipes look great! I did buy some potatoes this week, so I might make the potato dish. Cheers!
Thanks! I think you’ll love it as much as we did!
Both of your dishes look and sound amazing, Dot! This was the first time I’d heard of a potato kugel; the ones I’ve enjoyed are all made with pasta, and I think I’d like this one even better. Those Moroccan fish balls are right up your alley! Savory and simmered in tomato sauce. Perfect!
I loved both these dishes Terrie! As you said, right up my alley!!!
I do believe I could make the potatoes! They look delicious. The fish balls look good but I might leave out the fish? I love a good meatball and sauce recipe especially this time of year. Hugs, C
Hmm, a fish ball without fish, that would be unique!
The potatoes are great, I made them again for company and it was a hit. Potatoes!
I saved the potato kugel recipe. It sounds easy and delicious. Like you, I love potatoes. Thanks for sharing it Dorothy!!!!
I think you’ll enjoy this one Diane!