This chowder is dairy-free, but you’d never guess!
Many New Englanders and Canadians grew up with the classic Scottish Finnan Haddie, a delicately smoked haddock with a funny name. It was used in chowders and fish cakes when I was a kid, and was often served frequently during Lent. I loved the chowder the best. While Finnan Haddie refers to the actual smoked haddock, which originated in Findon, Scotland, I’m told (although there appears to be a little disagreement over the origins) the name was also commonly used around here for the chowder as well. At that time, the product was cheap, widely available, and a pound could stretch to feed the whole family.
A quick and easy chowder
The classic “Finnan Haddie” in our house when I was a kid was a simple chowder made by lightly simmering the smoked fish in water for 10 minutes or so, draining it (translation, throwing away a lot of flavor), skinning it and removing any bones. Then, an onion was sautéed, probably in salt pork, potatoes, milk, and a bay leaf added, cooked until tender, then the chunked fish returned to the pot. It was easy to make, and delicious, the Finnan Haddie having a distinctive, mild smoke flavor.
Thicken as you like
My Aunt Mary thickened her milk sauce with a roux, my mom did not. Instead, she added some potato flakes for a little extra body, so I’ve used her technique here since I’m not a fan of any chowder thickened with a thick flour roux. Look for a brand that has nothing but potatoes such as Bob’s Red Mill. Some brands are loaded with food additives, which are totally unnecessary. I also use the potato flakes as a coating on fried fish, such a lovely but subtle fried potato flavor!
My aunt also cooked hers without potatoes and served it almost gravy style over boiled potatoes. My mom included the potatoes with the milk making it more of a chowder.
Let’s save some flavor
I’ve poached my Finnan Haddie directly in the milk to retain every bit of flavor possible, but I did rinse it well beforehand to remove any excess salt. To deviate even more from mom’s technique, I added both parsley and green peas to give the chowder a little more visual interest. White potatoes. White sauce. White fish. Needed a little color.
To top it all off, I saved the potato peelings to make a crunchy, potato chip-like topping to add some texture.
Dairy or plant based, your choice
I’ve made this with non-dairy ingredients so all in my family can enjoy, but you can use whatever milk or cream you like. Mom would have used canned evaporated milk, which was quite delicious in this dish. Many recipes call for cream or light cream, but I don’t think this is necessary at all with the addition of the potato flakes. If you use cream, you probably won’t need the flakes.
Smoked haddock used to be everywhere, in even the smallest markets. It is not as easily found today, but you might see it around Lent at the larger fish markets in New England. If you don’t see it, ask your fish monger. I got mine from Stonington Seafood in Maine, and it was the best I’ve ever had. It is available mail order, pricey when you add in shipping, but worth it, and it freezes nicely.
The owner, Richard Penfold, learned hands-on about commercial fishing and to perfect smoking fish from master craftsmen on the Shetland Islands, more than a decade of work and research. He is a leading expert on the art today, and it shows in the quality of his product. His haddock is line caught on small boats, responsibly harvested, even better. The website has lots of other recipes for using the Finnan Haddie as well.
Smoke it yourself!
Of course, if you own a smoker, you can give it a try yourself in your own back yard! If you can’t obtain it anywhere, you can substitute smoked trout (would that be Finnan Troutie?), or any other favorite smoked fish. It won’t taste the same, as every smoked fish has a different flavor, but it will be delicious still. A bonus – if there is any left over, it will taste even better the next day.
Do you remember a similar dish?
Finnan Haddie Chowder with Potato Peel Topping
- 1 quart soy milk or dairy milk
- 2 bay leaves
- 2 star anise
- 1 lb. Finnan Haddie, rinsed
- 2 leeks, white and light green part, sliced, divided
- 1/3 cup white wine
- 1 ½ lb. yellow potatoes, diced
- 2 tbsp. dehydrated flaked potato (Bob’s Red Mill)
- 1 cup thawed frozen peas
- 2 packed tbsp. fresh parsley, minced
- Vegan or dairy butter, freshly ground black pepper
Prep the veggies: Peel the potatoes, dice them, and set the peelings aside, blotting them really dry. These crispy delights will become your topping. Slice the leeks and place a handful in a saucepan, about a third of them. Chop the stems off the parsley and throw those in too, along with the bay leaves and star anise. Add the milk and bring all to a very gentle simmer for 10 minutes so everyone can get acquainted. Meanwhile, rinse the Finnan Haddie to remove any excess salt.
Add the Finnan Haddie to the gently simmering milk and set your timer for four minutes. This will overcook easily, so watch the time carefully. Remove from heat, and let the fish sit in its bath for another two minutes, then carefully remove it, cover, and set aside to cool. Strain the milk into a bowl or glass measuring cup, and set that aside as well.
In your soup pot, add a tablespoon of butter and one of olive oil, and toss in the remaining leeks. Sauté until they are soft, no color, and add the wine and continue to cook until the wine has evaporated. Toss in the potatoes and the reserved milk. Bring to a simmer and let cook for about 15 minutes, or until the potatoes are tender.
While the potatoes cook, heat a half-inch of neutral oil in a large skillet over medium high and toss in the potato peelings. Let cook turning a couple of times, until browned and crisp. Drain on toweling, salt lightly.
Once the potatoes are cooked, add the peas, parsley, and the reserved haddock. Remove from heat, and let everything get warmed and flavorful together.
Place in a tureen, and add a bit of butter to the top and a few more sprigs of parsley. Top each bowl with some of the crispy potato skins.
© Copyright 2023– or current year, The New Vintage Kitchen. Unattributed use of this material is strictly prohibited. Reposting and links may be used, provided that credit is given to The New Vintage Kitchen, with active link and direction to this original post.
The New Vintage Kitchen does not accept ads or payment for mention of products or businesses.
Supporter of: Slow Food Fair Trade USA Northeast Organic Farmers Association EcoWatch Let’s Save Our Planet No Kid Hungry Hunger Free Vermont Environmental Working Group World Central Kitchen
51 Comments Add yours
Sounds absolutely wonderful! 😍🍃
Thank you! It definitely tickles the memory bones.
I’m like you, Dorothy. I use potato flakes to thicken soups and it adds so much flavor and creaminess. Great minds! 🤔✨💫
Thanks Judy! It’s really a delicious dish.
Dot, I loved that you used the potato skins for crunch. What kind of smoker do you use?
I don’t have a big smoker, although my son does and has great fun with it. His smoked turkey is amazing. I have one of those little dome smokers that just add a bit of smoke to things like butter and cheese. Because I’m not an experienced smoker, I let the experts do the fish smoking! Or maybe my son.
Sounds delicious. I’m going to look for smoked haddock to try it. Thanks for sharing.
Glad you enjoyed the recipe Staci! Good luck in your search.
Using crispy potato peels as garnish is genius Dorothy!
I love using every bit I can, and the first time I decided to fry up the peelings that would normally go in the compost, I was an immediate fan.
Well, we never used the name Finnan Haddie in my Sicilian home but on those occasions when my Dad had to work the night shift, my Mom would make me my favorite meal – cod fish cakes and chowder. Apparently I was the only one in the family who liked fish cakes and chowder – and I still do!
What a yummy recipe!
We used to make the fish cakes from salt cod. Just about everyone had salt cod and probably Finnan Haddie tucked in the refrigerator. The salt pork as well. Inexpensive at the time. The last time I priced salt cod, it was slightly more than fresh!
I love the different ways this was made by your mom and aunt!
I liked both ways, but loved mom’s the most. But I really love a seafood chowder of any sort.
This chowder looks so delicious and it is a favorite meal for us. I will need to sub the fish since haddie is not available where we live.
Have fun with it Jovina! It’s delicious no matter the smoked fish.
Great idea, to thicken with potato flakes and use the peels for crunchy topping.
You’ve definitely refreshed this traditional dish! 🙂
Thank you Ronit! I like this version more than what I grew up on!
My hubby wants to get a smoker. When he does, I could see him being all over this recipe!
My son loves his. He’s always trying something new in it!
I can just taste this! Lovely Friday night dinner! Winter is just round the corner for me and can see this being on the menu – even though I can’t get Haddock there is plenty of other local smoked fish that will be just as nice.
Wonderful Mary! Use whatever lovely local smoked fish you love, it will be delicious!
I really like the idea of using potato flakes to thicken the chowder—I will have to look for the Bob’s Red Mill Brand—I didn’t realize they made potato flakes!
It’s a really good product Nancy, and has one ingredient: dehydrated potatoes! No additives. If you look at the regular supermarket brands, there’s a whole list of the unpronounceable!
Thanks for posting that Dorothy! I’ll save it in case I ever find any smoked haddock. When I asked the fish dept. they suggested I use smoked cod, which just wasn’t the same. I remember the whole house would smell from the smoked haddock, but we only ever had it on Good Friday and considered it a real treat!
It was definitely a Lent dish when I was a kid. A nice good Friday ritual.
I’m sure the smoked cod would be good, but the haddock has its own unique flavor that makes it different from the other smoked fish.
Good luck hunter-gathering!
I’m not a fun of smoky foods but I would love to try this! It looks really delicious! Interesting that you’ve used potato flakes to make it a bit creamier…I’ve never used them yet ☺️
Thanks Ribana. I know smoked fish is not for everyone, but this has a mild smoky flavor so you might enjoy it.
Using the potato flakes as a thickener is an old trick both my mom and mother-in-law used. Works great!
So instead of working on the house, I’m reading your recipe out loud to the family. And can I just say we all love your potato topping! Everyone laughed out loud when I read, “add the milk and bring all to a very gentle simmer for 10 minutes so everyone can get acquainted.” You are such a fun food writer! Thanks for another good one, Dorothy! Hugs, C
Ah thanks! I’m glad I added a bit of comic relief to your gathering!
I’ve never heard of Finnan Haddie so no feelings about it one way or the other. It sounds good, but not sure about the potato peelings.
The peelings taste pretty much like potato chips, and in my book that’s a plus!
Hi, Dorothy – Your dishes look and sound so amazing they always make me want to change my dinner plans!
Thank you so much! There’s always tomorrow my friend!
Dorothy, the flaked potato is a great pearl in so far as, I’m sure, it could be used as a substitute in so many recipes. I’ll see if it can be bought at our regular supermarket.
You can use the flakes to thicken any soup or stew Carolyn, one of mom’s little tricks! Happy hunting!
I never heard of this fish having grown up in Pennsylvania. The recipe looks interesting, I’m going try it.
I hope you enjoy it Elaine! So tasty, and you can make your own memories!
Dorothy – Your dishes always looks amazing
Thank you so very much! The first bite is with the eyes!
Beautiful! I know I’d love this soup! And I love what you did with the peels!
They are like little potato chips on top. No complaints!
I LOVE smoked fish, I bet it gives this chowder the most wonderful flavor.
It’s really delicious, a treat for sure.
Crunchy Potato Peels! WOW! What a great idea. I would love this chowder and I bet it is filled with smokiness. YUM!
It’s so good! A flavor like none other!
I love the idea of using fried potato peels as a soup topper. It sounds delicious!
It’s really good Julia! I use it on mashed potatoes too!
Oh, that sounds lovely!