Snow Day! Winter Bean Soup with Crispy Shallot Topping

The kids had a snow day here today! Some of us are wondering why!

More rain, then snow

A little holiday cheer

Simmering soup

Soup with beans, yes, please

Winter Bean Soup with Crispy Shallot Topping

  • 2 tbsp. olive oil
  • 1 large onion, any type, diced
  • 2 stalks celery or some celery root, diced
  • 2 carrots, diced
  • 4 cloves garlic or so, minced
  • 1 tsp. fennel seeds, crushed
  • 2 tbsp. tomato paste
  • 1 quart or so root vegetables (beets, rutabaga, turnip, radishes, parsnips, potatoes, sweet potatoes, etc.) chopped as you like it
  • Water or stock to cover everything by an inch or so
  • 1 28-oz. can whole peeled tomatoes
  • 1 or 2 cups broccoli or cauliflower, chopped, or even some peas or green beans
  • 2 cups beans of choice
  • 2 heads shallots

Listen: Cher and Cyndi

© Copyright 2023– or current year, The New Vintage Kitchen. Dorothy Grover-Read. Unattributed use of this material is strictly prohibited. Reposting and links may be used, provided that credit is given to The New Vintage Kitchen, with  active link and direction to this original post.

The New Vintage Kitchen does not accept ads or payment for mention of products or businesses.

Supporter of:  Slow Food       Fair Trade USA       Northeast Organic Farmers Association     EcoWatch    Let’s Save Our Planet No Kid Hungry   Hunger Free Vermont Environmental Working Group World Central Kitchen Sustainable America

64 Comments Add yours

  1. So perfect for a winter dau.

    1. Thanks Jovina, it was indeed. And keeps delighting!

  2. Suzassippi says:

    This looks absolutely divine and giving me the urge to make some pinto beans…which I have had for a couple of weeks now and just haven’t done. Today could be the day!

    1. I love the smell of beans simmering. I used the pressure cooker this time, but the house still smelled wonderful, like the home of my childhood.
      We had a lot of beans.

  3. Misky says:

    We survive on wintery soup – leftovers into soup. Sunday roast chicken leftovers into soup. Old stale bread into tomato soup and blitzed. I have a question about reusing the oil, Dorothy. How long is it good for (as in safe) to use after frying the shallots when not reheated? Let’s say I want to use it for the base of salad dressing. I’m think salmonella, etc.

    1. Since you are straining out any bits of shallot, and even if you didn’t it is submerged in oil, the oil is safe until it goes rancid naturally.
      But don’t worry, it won’t last that long to even think about!

      1. Misky says:

        Excellent. Thank you, Dorothy.

  4. gabychops says:

    I love this soup, Dorothy, it is just my kind of things!
    I don’t like winter, and cannot wait for the spring!

    Joanna

    1. Already? I don’t usually get the winter blues until about the beginning of February.
      Just think of it this way, in another 11 days, the days will start getting longer and the light will return!

  5. NativeNM says:

    That sounds like the perfect day! I love your crispy shallots for topping, that sounds amazing!

  6. Love such hearty, yet not too heavy, soups. The crispy shallots on top is a great idea! 🙂

    1. I would make the soup just to have the shallots Ronit!

      1. lol totally understand! 🙂

  7. Wow that’s a lot of snow!! Warm vegetable soup sounds divine on days like this.

    1. We only ended up with about two inches, which around here isn’t enough to plow the driveway!

  8. Carolyn Page says:

    I’ve seen snow only a few times in my lifetime, Dorothy; I loved that peaceful quiet feeling that it brings. One of those times was when moving house – not so peaceful on the road, oops!
    This soup sounds delish. Even here in summer I love soup. We currently have a glut of tomatoes that I harvest daily. Home grown toms are finding their way into almost every dinner! Especially roasted…

    1. Well, when tomatoes are in season, especially at the tail end, I would definitely make this soup with the fresh!
      I’ll make a snowball for you!

  9. Soup looks good! My brain got stuck on “t-shirt weather for Vermonters.” Sometimes I see someone bundled up like the north pole, and I chuckle and know they definitely aren’t from New England. It was in the 40’s here with a brisk wind, and when I was in UPS there was a young guy in shorts, flip flops, and tshirt, and I thought he lives here. 🙂

    1. Our last carrier wore shorts all year long too!
      He was pretty cute…

  10. Kevin says:

    Mmm – I’m feeling warmer already!

    1. From the inside out!

  11. Gail says:

    Soups make the best winter meals, in my opinion. 🥘🍃😋

    1. Always! Steaming hot and inviting!🍜

      1. Gail says:

        Yes, Ma’am. 👏👏👏

  12. Looks delicious! I just made some bean soup and I’m going to make your Crispy Shallot Topping.

    1. I hope you love it as much as we do!!

  13. Chef Mimi says:

    Brrrr! Great soup recipe. I love no-recipe soups – it’s mostly what I do in my kitchen! Love the shallot topping.

    1. Thanks! The shallot topping is really tasty.

  14. Yum! I love soup. This one looks absolutely perfect — especially for our cooler weather. Thank you for sharing it.

    1. Thank you for stopping by! Soup so beautifully warms the body and mood!

  15. The first snowfall always brings a smile. I could eat those frizzled shallots on everything.

    1. Thanks Bernie!
      As I was eating the soup, I was thinking was a great topping the shallots would be on Mac and cheese!

  16. writinstuff says:

    Always love to add a new soup recipe to the rotation and I have a feeling I’ll be trying this one soon, possibly today. And those shallots? holy moly I can eat them on everything. Looks wonderful even if I have no snow days yet!

    1. Yes, you don’t need a snow day to make these shallots!

      1. Betty says:

        How much beans go in the soup. I didnt ser it listed in the ingredients. Sounds easy & yummy. Ty

        1. Thanks so much for noticing! I added two cups of beans to the recipe, but more or less is always up to you with a dish like this!

  17. This looks so good, D, and I bet those shallots are amazing! This is a keeper for sure!

    1. I had the idea that the shallots would be great topping a mac and cheese. Will try it on the granddaughter this week and let you all know, but I can guess!

      1. Oh, I can guess, too. And my grand loves mac & cheese!

        1. Carbs and cheese in any form!

  18. The crispy shallot topping sounds wonderful, and what a great idea to use the leftover oil on bread slices to go with you delicious soup!

    1. That left-over oil was the best part! So delicious brushed on toasted baguette.

  19. Rain plus wind plus snow! 😬 you deserve this hearty soup!

    1. It was deeply appreciated, the fire as well!

  20. lisinmayenne says:

    Mmm, perfect comfort food. 😊 If there are no beans, it’s not soup in my book! I love the idea of those crispy shallots on top but you are welcome to the snow! 😉

    1. As snowfalls go, this one was a baby. It left just enough on the grass to white everything up.

  21. Nancy says:

    Yes please! This is my kind of soup!
    And the crispy shallots are a perfect addition!

    1. Thanks Nancy! Nothing like a steaming bowl of soup on a cold day!

  22. Christy B says:

    A wonderful day of holiday cheer, Cher, and yummy soup, Dorothy! I feel like I was right there with you 🤗

    1. You were! I could have sworn I ladled you a bowl of soup!

      1. Christy B says:

        I’d come over for soup any time with you (or any other meal or beverage) 💗

  23. terrie gura says:

    You’ve got me craving soup, Dorothy! Nothing is better when winter weather arrives, and your bowl looks soooo inviting, especially with the crispy shallots! Did you happen to see Cher perform on TV at the Rockefeller Center tree lighting show? She did “Christmas (Baby, Please Come Home)” with Darlene Love… a throwback to the original when Cher sang backup! I never knew that and they did a great job as a duet.

    1. Great background info! She’s magnificent! At 77, she’s still going strong!

  24. Crazy weather calls for this comforting soup – yummy ingredients!

    1. Thank you Mary! Soup calls them all to the table!

  25. nancyc says:

    A snowy landscape really is beautiful! Sounds like you had a cozy and happy snow day! 🙂

    1. It was nice! But the snow is already gone, and more rain predicted for the next few days!

  26. Anonymous says:

    Crispy Shallots. A brilliant idea…thank you Dorothy1

    1. You’re very welcome! Always love to share the tasty!

  27. Looks delicious and those shallots!!!!! Love soup season!

    1. I’m always ready for those shallots!

  28. Dorothy, soup is one of my favorites all year long. The colder month soups are soul satisfying. This is a beautiful ‘Snow Day’ soup.

    Cheers from Florida.

    Velva

    1. Thank you ! It sure takes the edge off a snowy, or rainy, day.

Please leave your valued comment here...